Cave Swallow (Petrochelidon fulva)
One of my favourite walking routes is a 5 km stretch of Lake Erie coast, along beaches, over dunes, past wetlands and scrubby bush, which even in December, can produce a good diversity of birds, including fantastic counts of waterfowl. Sometimes, this walk offers up a particularly nice surprise, like the one that came in the form of three Cave Swallows (Petrochelidon fulva), just the other day. Cave Swallows are rare in Ontario, but they do occur nearly every autumn, and the reasons behind their late-season appearance are still a little unclear, but is a probably a combination of factors, including far-ranging weather systems, population ecology and life history traits.
Usually, Cave Swallows begin to appear in Ontario in late October through November, with some birds lingering (or even arriving) as late as December, when the weather allows. Almost all of Ontario's records are from the north shores of Lakes Erie and Ontario, with a few scattered observations elsewhere. Movements into Ontario seem to be almost invariably preceded by strong southerly winds, sometimes in the form of hurricanes and tropical storms, or as more subdued systems which channel warm air out of the southern United States and into the Great Lakes basin. In late fall and even early winter, when southern winds are blowing, it's time to start looking for Cave Swallows. It's not just Ontario that receives these apparent reverse migrations of swallows, the southern Atlantic states, for example, also experience such events.
But why is it the Cave Swallow, of all the possible species, that gets blown north each fall? There are likely a number of factors at work, the first being the phenomenal population increase this species has undergone in Texas since its first breeding record in 1915. Texas's Cave Swallows have increased their breeding range by an estimated 898% since 1957, with concomitant increases in the numbers of both breeding and overwintering birds, particularly in the 1990's. Ontario records may reflect the assent of Cave Swallows, to some degree; the first record of Cave Swallows in Ontario was in 1989, and near-annual autumn movements began in 1998. Species that experience such explosive population growth and range expansion, also seem to be most prone to producing vagrants, in part because young birds may be disperse widely in search of new, less densely populated breeding sites.
There are also life history traits that may mean Cave Swallows are particularly good candidates for vagrancy. Being aerialists, swallows are more likely than other birds, to be sucked into weather systems. Because they are such gifted fliers, Cave Swallows could potentially ride systems longer than other species, which may need to drop out to rest before reaching the Great Lakes. That's not to say that other species don't arrive as vagrants in association with the same kinds of weather patterns that bring the swallows. Currently, there is a western flycatcher (Empidonax sp) in Ohio, and a Vermilion Flycatcher (Pyrocephalus rubinus), a Bullock's Oriole (Icterus bullockii) and a couple of Mountain Bluebirds (Sialia currucoides) in Ontario, plus a Black-throated Grey Warbler (Setophaga nigrescens) in western Quebec. These species could have all been brought north on the same weather systems that have been shuttling Cave Swallows into the Great Lakes basin this fall. Birders should use Cave Swallows as an alert system: when the Cave Swallow Express rolls in, there may other rarities on board.
